Solidus vs Shopify vs Shopware vs Magento vs WooCommerce: which platform for a UK shop that sells into Germany and Austria
TL;DR
Difficulty: Intermediate
The real choice is renting or owning. Shopify is the best rented platform, but below Plus (from £1,800 a month) apps cannot change the payment steps of the checkout, and external payment providers cost 0.6% to 2% extra per order. Shopware's free edition needs a paid plan above €1 million of sales to keep store access. Magento is capable but costly to run and upgrade. WooCommerce suits small, content led shops with someone patching plugins. Solidus costs more in year one, needs a Rails developer, and then has no licence, no revenue share and no ceiling. Check the order button, unit prices, invoice payment, VAT and accessibility first.
Shopify, Shopware, Magento, WooCommerce and Solidus can all run a good shop. What separates them is who owns the shop, what the platform charges you every month for five years, how they handle the rules of each market you sell into, and how hard they are to leave. I build on Solidus, so every fact about the other four comes from the vendor's own pages as of November 2026, and each keeps its genuine strengths. I put list prices into a five year sum for an invented Leeds homeware shop that also sells to Germany and Austria.
The decision behind the platform: rent or own
Sooner or later a growing shop asks the same question. The app bill has crept past the plan fee, a small change to the checkout has been quoted at weeks, or the vendor has announced that the version you run is reaching the end of its support. What should the shop be on instead?
This is my long answer, written for UK shops, including the many that sell into Germany and Austria or plan to. I build on Solidus, so you know where I stand. That is exactly why every fact about the other four platforms below comes from the vendor's own pages as of November 2026, with a footnote, and why each one keeps its genuine strengths. If Shopify is the right answer for your business, this article should tell you so.
It is written for the person who signs the invoice. Your developer will have views on PHP against Ruby, and they are welcome, but they do not decide whether the shop makes money in 2031. What decides that is who owns the shop, what it costs over five years, whether it does what customers in each market expect at the checkout, where the customisation stops, and how hard it is to leave. That is the order I take.
Strip the marketing off all five platforms and two models remain.
Renting. Shopify is the pure form. You pay monthly, the vendor runs everything, you customise within the boundaries it sets, and when you stop paying the shop is gone. Shopware sits in between: its Community Edition is open source, but since March 2025 a shop above €1 million of annual sales needs a paid plan to keep access to Shopware's account and extension store.1 Adobe Commerce, the paid Magento, is licensed software that you either host yourself or run on Adobe's cloud.
Owning. Solidus, Magento Open Source and WooCommerce are code you run. Nobody can switch them off and nobody takes a percentage. The flip side is that nobody else is responsible for them either, and anyone who has owned an old house knows what that means.
My rough rule is simple. If ecommerce is one sales channel among several and the shop itself is not where you compete, rent. If the shop is the business, if the way people buy from you is part of why they buy from you, own. A trade supplier with customer specific price lists, a brand with a product configurator, a retailer with click and collect across several branches, a subscription box: these businesses tend to reach the walls of a rented platform, and then they pay twice, once for the workarounds and once for the move.
Everything below is detail on that one distinction.
Shopify: the best rented platform, with a locked checkout below Plus
Shopify is the best product in this list at what it does. The admin is pleasant, hosting and platform security are handled for you, Shopify Payments works in the UK, Ireland, Germany, Austria and Switzerland,2 and a founder can have a shop live in a weekend. In Austria, Shopify Payments now carries Klarna, EPS and TWINT at published rates,3 which removes some of the old pain of selling into the region.
The UK prices, billed yearly, are £19 a month for Basic, £49 for Grow and £259 for Advanced (£25, £65 and £344 billed monthly). Plus starts at £1,800 a month on a one or three year term.4 Three things show up as a shop grows.
The checkout. On every plan below Plus, apps cannot customise the information, shipping and payment steps of the checkout. They can only extend the thank you and order status pages.5 The old way round it, checkout.liquid, is no longer supported for those steps, and it was switched off for the thank you and order status pages on 28 August 2025.6 A custom field at the payment step, an extra step for a delivery slot, a different flow for trade customers: that is Plus territory, and Plus is a line you pay every month for as long as you stay.
The apps. A real shop usually runs a string of them: reviews, bundles, legal texts for each market, a consent banner, invoices your accountant will accept, back in stock alerts, search, translations, a trade add on. Each is a monthly fee, and each is another company handling your customer data, which under the GDPR means another processor contract.7 The app line is the one owners most often leave out of the budget.
The fees. If you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments, Shopify adds a third party transaction fee on every order processed through it: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus.4 PayPal is exempt when Shopify Payments is your primary provider.8 If your German invoice payment partner or a better negotiated card rate sits outside Shopify Payments, this fee is the price of that choice.
Then there is the exit. Products, customers and orders export as CSV files. The theme is Liquid and stays behind, the apps stay behind, and the URLs follow Shopify's structure. None of that is a scandal. It is what renting means, and you should price it in.
Where Shopify is right: new brands, small catalogues, businesses where the shop is a channel rather than the moat, and anyone who does not want to own software. If that is you, pick a theme and spend your energy on product and marketing.
Shopware: the German default, and what has changed
Ask a German agency what to build on and the answer is very often Shopware. There are good reasons. It is made in Germany, its core thinks in German legal requirements, invoice payment integrations are mature, and the extension store has a German legal texts plugin for most situations. For a shop that sells mainly in Germany and Austria, that ecosystem is a real advantage.
The licensing picture changed in two steps. In February 2022 Shopware took its first outside investment, 100 million US dollars from Carlyle and PayPal.9 Then, from 24 March 2025, a fair usage policy applies to the Community Edition: shops linked to an account with more than €1 million of sales over the preceding 365 days need a paid plan to keep access to the Shopware Account and Store, and every Community Edition user reports sales volume to Shopware.101 The code itself stays under the permissive MIT licence, and Shopware says the policy does not touch that licence.1 The paid plans start at €600 a month for Rise and €2,400 a month for Evolve, excluding VAT, with Beyond priced individually, and pricing is based on sales volume and other factors.10
Two further points are worth weighing for a small or mid sized shop.
Major version changes. Shopware 5 received only security fixes from the end of July 2023 and none from Shopware after the end of July 2024, and moving to Shopware 6 was in practice a rebuild with a data import.11 Magento went through the same with version 2. It should temper any "we will just upgrade later" assumption, whatever the platform.
Agency dependence. Because the ecosystem is agency led, many Shopware shops depend on one agency for anything beyond editing products. That is fine while the relationship is good. Before you sign, ask for custom plugins to be documented and delivered into a repository you control.
Where Shopware is right: a retailer focused on Germany and Austria, with a conventional catalogue, a budget for an agency, and a preference for a vendor every local agency knows. If you sell above €1 million a year, read the paid plan pricing before you fall for the free edition.
Magento: capable, and expensive to run well
Magento Open Source is serious software. It handles very large catalogues, complex B2B, multiple stores and currencies. Adobe Commerce, the paid version, adds features and a licence fee that Adobe does not publish and quotes through sales.
The difficulty for a small or mid sized shop is not capability, it is the cost of operating it. A properly run Magento 2 store needs a search engine such as OpenSearch, a cache, cron jobs that behave and a hosting setup sized for all of it, and the work is usually done at agency rates. Adobe publishes fixed support windows for each release of the 2.4 line: 2.4.6 left standard support on 11 August 2026, 2.4.7 leaves it on 31 May 2027, 2.4.8 on 31 May 2028 and 2.4.9, released on 12 May 2026, on 31 May 2029.12 That means a planned upgrade project every year or two.
Two developments soften the picture. The Hyvä frontend, which many agencies use to replace Magento's slow default theme, became free and open source in November 2025, while Hyvä Checkout and some other products stay paid.13 And a non profit association runs Mage-OS, a community distribution of Magento Open Source founded out of concern for the open source edition's future.14
Where Magento is right: you already have it, it works, and you have the budget to keep it upgraded. Or you are a large B2B operation with a huge catalogue and an in house team. Neither describes the typical SME, and I would not start a new SME shop on it today.
WooCommerce: WordPress with a till
WooCommerce is free, open source, and runs on more than 7 million WordPress sites.15 If you already have a WordPress site with a good content operation and want to sell a modest catalogue, it is the obvious answer and I would not argue with it.
Beyond that, three things deserve attention.
Security. Patchstack counted 11,334 new vulnerabilities in the WordPress ecosystem in 2025, 91% of them in plugins and 9% in themes, with only six in WordPress core. 46% had no fix from the developer by the time they were disclosed.16 A real WooCommerce shop runs many plugins, and each one is a door to keep shut. A breach that affects personal data has to be reported to the regulator within 72 hours where feasible, under the GDPR and the UK GDPR alike.7 In the UK that regulator is now the Information Commission, formerly the ICO.
Performance at scale. Products are stored as WordPress posts with metadata. Past a few thousand products or a busy order flow, the shop needs the kind of caching and hosting attention that eats into the "free" in the price.
Market rules come from plugins. Selling legally to German consumers needs unit prices, the right order button, withdrawal texts and delivery times, and in WooCommerce that comes from a plugin such as Germanized, whose free version adjusts the order button and shows unit prices, with automatic unit price calculation and invoices in the paid Pro version.17 It is a good plugin. It is also a dependency on one small company for whether your shop is compliant, and every update is a check that the pieces still fit.
Where WooCommerce is right: content led businesses, small catalogues, and anyone who already lives in WordPress and has someone who keeps it patched. Write down the revenue at which you will reconsider, before an incident makes the decision for you.
Solidus: the one you own outright
Now the one I build on, and I will be as hard on it as on the others.
Solidus is an open source ecommerce framework written in Ruby on Rails. It is a fork of Spree, licensed under the three clause BSD licence, and Nebulab is currently its main code contributor and director.18 It is actively maintained: version 4.8.0 shipped on 9 October 2026 and patch releases for 4.6, 4.7 and 4.8 followed on 5 November 2026.19 It is not a product you install and click through. It is a set of building blocks (orders, products, variants, stock locations, promotions, payments, shipping, tax) that you assemble into a shop, with an admin on top and a starter storefront to build from.
The honest drawbacks first.
You cannot launch a Solidus shop in a weekend. There is no theme store and no marketplace of hundreds of plugins. The storefront is yours to build, which is excellent if you want a shop that looks like your brand and expensive if you just want a shop. Year one costs more than a Shopify launch.
You need someone who knows Rails. Far fewer agencies work with Solidus than with Shopify or Shopware. That is a real constraint, and it is the first thing to check before choosing it.
The extension ecosystem is small. There are official integrations for payments (Stripe, PayPal Commerce Platform, Braintree, Klarna and others), tax (Avalara, TaxCloud), content, marketing, shipping and fraud detection.20 For anything else the answer is usually "build it", not "install it". For a shop with a conventional catalogue and no unusual requirements, that is a cost without a matching benefit.
Major versions need work. Solidus follows semantic versioning strictly. Minor releases add deprecation warnings while the shop keeps working, and a new major version, which the project aims to release at least every two years, removes the deprecated code.21 On a well tested shop that is planned maintenance rather than a rebuild, but it is not free.
And the reasons I chose it anyway.
Nobody owns you. No licence fee, no revenue share, no plan tier that unlocks your own checkout. The BSD licence lets you do almost anything with the code, including keep your changes private. Hosting is whatever you choose, and deployment can use Kamal, the tool 37signals built to move HEY and its other applications onto its own servers.22
Everything is customisable. The checkout is a set of Rails controllers and views. A step that asks for a delivery slot, an order total that follows a trade customer's negotiated price list, a build your own hamper where the customer picks a fixed number of items: each is ordinary application code, written with tests. On Shopify the same feature is often an app with a monthly fee and a compromise, and on Shopware a plugin and a quote.
It is a Rails application, and behaves like one. That sounds like a developer point but it is a business one. You get the same testing tools, deployment, security scanning and hiring pool as any other Rails application, and the shop can share code with your customer portal or internal tools. I describe how I test in my piece on Cucumber: every feature in the shop has an executable specification that you, the owner, can read.
The API comes with it. Solidus ships with a REST API, so the shop can feed a mobile app, a marketplace or a second storefront without an upgrade tier.18
Where Solidus is right: shops where the buying experience is part of the product. B2B with price lists and quotes, configurators and bundles, multi location retail, subscriptions, anything that must integrate deeply with an ERP, a warehouse or a bespoke process, and brands that want a shop that looks like nothing else.
The checklist, at home and in Germany and Austria
Owners compare platforms on features and design. Shops actually fail on the regulated basics. Put every candidate through this list before you look at a single theme. The German and Austrian items apply as soon as you sell to consumers there.
The order button. In the UK the button must say "order with obligation to pay" or an equally unambiguous phrase, and the essential information must sit directly before it.23 Germany has the same rule, with "zahlungspflichtig bestellen" as the model wording,24 and Austria the same in the FAGG.25 Every platform can do this, but check it in each language.
Unit prices. Goods sold by weight, volume, length or area need a price per unit next to the total price, under the Price Marking Order in the UK and the Preisangabenverordnung in Germany.2627 Shopware and the WooCommerce German plugins do this out of the box. On Shopify it is an app or theme work. On Solidus it is a field and a line in the template, which someone has to remember to build.
Kauf auf Rechnung. Paying by invoice after delivery accounted for 26.1% of German online retail turnover in 2025, second only to PayPal at 28.7%, according to the EHI study Online Payment 2026.28 For a shop selling into Germany it is not optional, and for trade customers even less so. The difference between platforms is what happens when the customer does not pay, how reminders run, and whether your accounts see it correctly. I cover the methods in detail in DACH payments in Solidus, and the broader buying habits in how German buyers pay.
SEPA, EPS, TWINT. Direct debit for Germany, EPS bank transfers for Austria,29 TWINT for Switzerland. Giropay is gone: it was wound up at the end of 2024.30 The checkout should show the right methods to the right customer and nothing else. On a rented platform that is a settings page, if the method is supported. On Solidus it is a rule you write once and test.
VAT on sales into the EU. A UK shop sending goods from Britain to EU consumers is importing them into the EU. For consignments up to €150 the Import One Stop Shop lets you charge and report the VAT at the checkout. The EU wide €10,000 threshold and the One Stop Shop for distance sales apply to sellers whose goods move within the EU, which matters the day you hold stock in an EU warehouse.31 Every platform can charge a rate. Not every platform produces a report your accountant can file without a spreadsheet at quarter end, so ask to see the export. My cross border setup guide covers the registrations.
Invoices for German customers. Since 1 January 2025 every German business must be able to receive electronic invoices in the EN 16931 format, and German businesses move to issuing them by the end of 2026, or the end of 2027 with up to €800,000 of prior year turnover.32 Expect your German trade customers to ask for XRechnung or ZUGFeRD files. If you set up a German company or register for VAT in Germany, German bookkeeping rules apply to you as well: a record may not be changed in a way that hides its original content, and every invoice needs a unique sequential number.3334 Electronic invoices on Shopify and WooCommerce come from an app or plugin, Shopware covers them with extensions, and on Solidus they are part of the build, worth getting right the first time.
Accessibility. The European Accessibility Act has applied to ecommerce services for consumers in the EU since 28 June 2025.35 Germany implements it in the BFSG, which exempts micro enterprises (fewer than ten staff and no more than €2 million of turnover or balance sheet) that provide services.36 In the UK, the Equality Act requires reasonable adjustments for disabled customers.37 In practice the storefront should meet WCAG 2.1 AA. Theme based platforms depend on the theme's quality. A custom storefront is only as good as its specification, which is an argument for writing accessibility into it, not for or against any platform. The detail is in my accessibility piece.
Processors. Every app, plugin and hosted service that touches customer data is a processor you need a contract with.7 Twenty apps are twenty processors. A self hosted Solidus shop with Stripe and a transactional email provider has two.
The five year bill: what you can calculate today
Here I put numbers on it, but only the numbers that come from price lists. Build work, agency retainers and maintenance vary too much between shops to state as ranges without a specification, so they are the part you need quotes for.
Take an invented business: Holbeck Home (holbeckhome.example), a Leeds homeware shop with £1.5 million of online revenue, of which £300,000 a year goes to customers in Germany and Austria, paid by invoice through an external provider. The five year platform rent is
where is the platform cost over five years, the monthly plan fee, the monthly app spend, the third party transaction fee as a share, and the revenue in year that runs through a provider other than Shopify Payments. I leave card processing out, because every platform pays a payment provider, and I do not discount future years (see percentages and discounting in the Foundations reference if you want to).
On Shopify Advanced billed yearly, . Assume, for illustration, apps at a month, and on :
So comes to £48,540 of rent over five years before any design or agency work, and the checkout is still locked. On Grow the plan costs £2,940 over five years but the fee on the external provider rises to 1%, £15,000. Plus starts at £108,000 over five years for the plan alone.
On Shopware, Rise starts at €36,000 over five years and Evolve at €144,000, both before VAT. Holbeck Home's turnover is above the €1 million line, so the free Community Edition would mean giving up access to the Shopware Account and Store.101 Solidus, Magento Open Source and WooCommerce cost nothing in licence fees, and Adobe Commerce's licence is quoted individually.
What the rent comparison cannot show is the other half. On an owned platform, almost the whole bill is work: the build, hosting, upgrades, security scanning and new features. That is why Solidus costs more in year one than a Shopify theme launch, and why its bill is mostly spent on features that become yours rather than on rent. Whether that adds up for your shop depends on quotes for your specification. For a full worked example that includes build, migration and maintenance, read the five year total cost of ownership. My own rates are on the pricing page.
And the cost that matters most is not on any list: the thing you cannot do. The trade price list you cannot build without Plus, the checkout step that becomes a compromise, the migration a vendor forces on you when a version ends.
The customisation ceiling
Every platform has a point where the answer to "can we do this" moves from "yes" to "sort of" to "not really". Knowing where it sits matters more than any feature list.
Shopify. Themes and content: high. Checkout: low below Plus, wider on Plus. Business logic such as pricing, stock and order flow: limited to what apps and Shopify's extension points allow.
Shopware. Themes: high, with effort. Checkout and business logic: high, because it is a real application framework underneath. The ceiling is usually your agency, not the software.
Magento. Everything: high. The ceiling is your budget.
WooCommerce. Themes: high. Checkout: medium, and fragile. Business logic: medium, and every customisation makes the next update riskier.
Solidus. Everything: high, with no vendor layer between you and the code. The ceiling is whether you have a Rails developer, and how much you want to build rather than install.
How you leave
Ask every candidate one question before you sign: if I want to move in four years, what do I take with me?
From Shopify you take CSV exports of products, customers and orders, not the theme, the apps or the checkout. From Shopware you take your database and custom plugins, most useful if the next platform is Shopware again. From Magento you take a large database and a set of modules, and the migration is priced accordingly. From WooCommerce you take a WordPress database in which products are posts, exportable but untidy.
From Solidus you take a Rails application and a PostgreSQL database that you already own, on servers you already control. You can hand it to a different Rails developer tomorrow. That is the point of owning, and bespoke code I write becomes yours on full payment.
Hosting and security, briefly
Rented platforms handle hosting and the security of the platform itself. That is a genuine benefit and the strongest argument for Shopify. They do not handle the security of your apps, your staff accounts or your integrations, which is where many incidents start.
Owned platforms are your responsibility, so they are as secure as the people running them. For Solidus that means the standard Rails toolchain: static analysis with Brakeman, dependency auditing, a security test before major releases, and a deployment that exposes nothing it should not. I build that into every shop and keep the evidence, so there is something to show when an auditor or an insurer asks. For Magento it means ongoing hosting and patching attention. For WooCommerce it means keeping every plugin patched, for as long as the shop runs.
Who should pick what
Pick Shopify if you are launching, if your catalogue and checkout are conventional, if the shop is a channel rather than the business, or if you do not want to own software. Budget for the apps, and know that the checkout is not yours below Plus.
Pick Shopware if you sell mainly in Germany and Austria, want a vendor every local agency knows, and have the budget for an agency and, above €1 million of sales, a paid plan.
Stay on Magento if you are already there, it works, and you can fund the upgrade cycle. Do not start there.
Pick WooCommerce if you are a content business with a small catalogue and someone who keeps WordPress patched. Set the revenue at which you will reconsider, and write it down.
Pick Solidus if the way people buy from you is part of what you sell, if you need what other platforms call "enterprise" and charge for accordingly, or if you have done the five year maths and would rather spend the money on your own shop than on rent. Accept that year one costs more and that you need a Rails developer you trust. If you are moving across, the migration and cost article walks through it, and the mistakes British businesses make when expanding into Germany and Austria are worth reading before you add the second market.
If you want a second opinion on your own numbers, I run a free workshop, and the first two weeks of work are on me. I will tell you which platform I would pick for you, and it will not always be mine.