Why working with me as a contractor can benefit you

TL;DR

Difficulty: Beginner

  • A UK employee costs the salary plus about 16% in statutory on costs (employer National Insurance at 15% above £5,000, a 3% pension), about 22% with kit, and about 42% in the year you pay a recruiter.
  • A senior contractor costs more per productive day and less per year, because you buy only the days you need and carry none of the fixed obligations.
  • The break even is the employee's annual cost divided by the day rate. In the worked example it is about 130 days of senior work a year. Below that, work with a contractor. Above it, hire, and I will say so.
  • IR35 is a test of whether the engagement is genuine. Scoped deliverables, own kit, several clients and a right of substitution pass it.

If you need senior technical capability without growing the headcount, this is the honest case for working with one senior contractor instead of hiring or using an agency. Every employment cost comes from GOV.UK with a reference, every assumption is labelled, and an invented furniture business in Leeds runs the sums for a full year, including the number of days at which hiring becomes the better answer.

What you are actually buying

When a managing director tells me "we need a developer", they rarely need a developer. They need a checkout that stops losing orders, a shop that talks to the warehouse, or a product that ships before the trade show. The developer is the means. The question underneath is simpler and more useful: how do I buy senior capability for exactly as long as I need it, without taking on more than I can carry?

There are three ways to buy it. You hire someone. You hand it to an agency. Or you work with one senior person who does the work with their own hands and answers for it. I am the third option, and this article is the honest case for it, with the numbers.

Every employment figure below comes from GOV.UK and is referenced. Every number I had to assume is labelled as an assumption, so you can swap in your own. And I will tell you where the sums favour hiring, because they sometimes do, and a contractor who pretends otherwise is not one you want.

An example: I will use one invented business throughout. Calder Street Interiors sells made to order furniture from a showroom in Leeds and an online shop that does about £3 million a year with eight staff. The managing director, Rachel, has a list of technical work for the coming year: a new checkout, a stock feed from the workshop, a proper B2B price list for trade customers, and a stack of smaller fixes. She is weighing a full time hire against a contractor. Nobody at Calder Street is real.

What an employee costs beyond the salary

The salary is the number everybody knows. It is also the number that misleads, because employing someone in the UK adds a set of statutory costs on top, and the costs that are not statutory are easy to forget.

Here is the list for the 2026 to 2027 tax year, each with its source.

Employer National Insurance. On top of the salary, the employer pays Class 1 National Insurance at 15% on everything the employee earns above the secondary threshold of £5,000 a year.1 Employment Allowance lets eligible employers knock up to £10,500 a year off their total employer National Insurance bill,2 which matters a great deal for a first hire and very little once you have a payroll of eight.

Workplace pension. Automatic enrolment obliges the employer to pay at least 3% of the employee's qualifying earnings into a pension. Qualifying earnings are the band between £6,240 and £50,270 a year.3 Those figures were frozen at their 2025 to 2026 levels for 2026 to 2027.4 Many employers pay more than the minimum, and I use the minimum below.

Paid holiday. A full time worker on a five day week is entitled to at least 28 days of paid leave a year, which is 5.6 weeks, and the employer may count bank holidays inside that.5 This is not a cash cost on top of the salary. It is paid time in which no work arrives, and it matters when you work out what an hour of actual work costs.

Sick pay. Statutory Sick Pay is £123.25 a week, paid by the employer for up to 28 weeks.6 Small in money, but again it is paid time with no work in it.

Employers' liability insurance. The moment you become an employer you must hold cover of at least £5 million, and the fine for not holding it is £2,500 for every day you are without it.7 If you already employ people you already have it, so one more hire adds little or nothing.

The apprenticeship levy. Charged at 0.5% of the annual pay bill, with a £15,000 allowance, so in practice only employers with a pay bill above £3 million pay it.1 Calder Street does not.

Then the costs that no statute sets but every employer pays: a laptop, software licences, a desk or a remote working allowance, and the cost of finding the person in the first place. Recruitment agencies charge a percentage of the first year's salary, and the percentage varies widely, so I treat it as an assumption you should replace with your own quote.

Put together, the total cost of an employee for a year is a sum of parts:

C=S+NI+P+K+RC = S + NI + P + K + R

Here CC is the total cost of employment for the year, SS the gross salary, NINI the employer National Insurance, PP the employer pension contribution, KK the kit, tools and workspace, and RR the recruitment cost. The step that makes this sum useful is ordinary percentage arithmetic (Foundations: percentages). The on costs are the parts other than the salary, expressed as a share of the salary:

on costs=C−SS×100\text{on costs} = \frac{C - S}{S} \times 100

The result is the percentage change from SS to CC, the same arithmetic as any other percentage change: Foundations: percentages.

Worked example: Calder Street Interiors hires a developer

Rachel decides to hire a senior Rails developer. The salary is £65,000. That is my assumption for a senior developer in Leeds, and you should put in whatever the market quotes you.

Employer National Insurance is 15% of everything above £5,000:

NI=(65,000−5,000)×0.15=9,000NI = (65{,}000 - 5{,}000) \times 0.15 = 9{,}000

So NINI, the employer National Insurance on a salary SS of £65,000, is £9,000 a year.

Calder Street already uses its Employment Allowance against the National Insurance for the existing eight staff, so none of it is left for this hire. That is an assumption, and a realistic one once a payroll is past its first two or three people.

The pension is 3% of qualifying earnings. A salary of £65,000 is above the top of the band, so the band is capped at £50,270:

P=(50,270−6,240)×0.03=44,030×0.03=1,320.90P = (50{,}270 - 6{,}240) \times 0.03 = 44{,}030 \times 0.03 = 1{,}320.90

So PP, the employer pension contribution, is £1,320.90 a year on the capped band of qualifying earnings.

Kit and tools: a laptop, monitors, software subscriptions, a share of the office. I assume £4,000 for the year. Recruitment: an agency finds the developer for a fee of 20% of the salary, which is £13,000. Both are assumptions.

The total for year one:

C=65,000+9,000+1,320.90+4,000+13,000=92,320.90C = 65{,}000 + 9{,}000 + 1{,}320.90 + 4{,}000 + 13{,}000 = 92{,}320.90

So CC for year one is £92,320.90, of which RR, the recruitment fee, is £13,000. In the second year there is no recruitment fee, so the running cost is £79,320.90.

A bar chart of the five parts of the first year cost of employing a developer at Calder Street Interiors: salary 65,000, employer National Insurance 9,000, pension 1,321, kit and tools 4,000, recruitment 13,000 pounds. Tap or click to open full screen and move around

The bars are the five parts of the first year cost, in pounds. The salary dominates, as it should. The point of the chart is the other four bars together: £27,321 on top of a £65,000 salary, which is on costs of 42.0% in year one. Strip out recruitment and the running on costs are £14,321, or 22.0%. The two statutory items alone, National Insurance and the pension, come to £10,321, or 15.9%.

I mention those three figures because an older version of this article said that employing someone adds somewhere between 30% and 50% to the salary. I could not trace that figure to a source, so it is gone. What you have instead is a range you can rebuild yourself: about 16% from the law alone, about 22% once the person has a desk and a laptop, and about 42% in the year you pay someone to find them.

Why the contractor costs more per day and less per year

Here is the part of the argument most contractors skip, because it does not flatter them. Per day, I cost more than an employee. The saving is not in the rate. It is in buying only the days you need, and in the absence of everything in the list above.

To compare fairly you need the cost of a day in which work actually happens. An employee is paid for 260 weekdays a year, but 28 of them are holiday, and some are sickness. What is left are the productive days:

cost per productive day=C260−H−D\text{cost per productive day} = \frac{C}{260 - H - D}

Here CC is the total cost of employment, HH the days of paid holiday and DD the days of sickness. It is a rate, a cost divided by the opportunities to do work, so the denominator matters as much as the numerator: Foundations: ratios and rates.

Worked example: the same year, bought by the day

Calder Street's developer has 28 days of holiday. I assume five days of sickness. Productive days:

260−28−5=227260 - 28 - 5 = 227

That is the 260 weekdays less H=28H = 28 days of holiday and D=5D = 5 days of sickness.

Cost per productive day in year one, and in a steady year:

92,320.90227=406.7079,320.90227=349.43\frac{92{,}320.90}{227} = 406.70 \qquad \frac{79{,}320.90}{227} = 349.43

The first is CC for year one over the 227 productive days, £406.70 a day. The second is the steady year, £349.43 a day.

Now the contractor. Assume a senior day rate of £600. That is an assumption for the sum, not a quote, and my own pricing is on the pricing page. On a day, the contractor is £600 against £349.43. The employee is less expensive per day by a clear margin, and anyone who tells you otherwise has not done the division.

But Rachel does not need 227 days of senior development. When I scope her list in the workshop, the checkout, the stock feed, the B2B price list and the fixes come to about 90 days of senior work spread across the year. That is an assumption too, and the one you should test hardest in your own case, because it decides everything.

Ninety days at £600 is £54,000. No National Insurance, because I am not your employee. No pension, no holiday pay, no sick pay, no laptop, no recruitment fee. If I am ill, you do not pay for that day. If a month is quiet, you buy no days that month. The contractor also charges VAT, which Calder Street reclaims as a VAT registered business, so I leave it out of the comparison.

The year, side by side: £92,320.90 for the hire, £54,000 for the contractor. Not because the contractor is less expensive, but because Rachel bought 90 days instead of paying for 260 and using 227.

There is a second cost the sum cannot show. On the days there is no senior work, Rachel still has a senior developer to keep busy, and work expands to fill the person.

Where the two lines cross

If the contractor is more expensive per day and less expensive per year at 90 days, there must be a number of days where they are equal. There is, and it is the most useful number in this article.

d∗=Crd^* = \frac{C}{r}

Here d∗d^* is the break even number of days, CC the annual cost of the employee and rr the contractor's day rate. Below d∗d^* days of real work a year, the contractor costs less in total. Above it, the hire does. The division itself is the plain ratio explained in Foundations: ratios and rates.

For Calder Street, with the steady state cost:

d∗=79,320.90600=132.2d^* = \frac{79{,}320.90}{600} = 132.2

That is d∗d^* with CC at £79,320.90 and rr at £600: about 132 days. And in the first year, with the recruitment fee inside CC:

d∗=92,320.90600=153.9d^* = \frac{92{,}320.90}{600} = 153.9

Now CC is £92,320.90 and d∗d^* rises to about 154 days.

A line chart comparing the yearly cost of a contractor at 600 pounds a day, rising from 18,000 at 30 days to 126,000 at 210 days, with the flat cost of an employee at 79,321 in a steady year and 92,321 in year one. The lines cross at about 132 and 154 days. Tap or click to open full screen and move around

The horizontal axis is how many days of senior work your business needs in a year. The vertical axis is what that year costs. The contractor's line rises with every day you buy. The two employee lines are flat, because you pay the salary whether the work is there or not. The takeaway is the crossing point: at around 130 days of genuine senior work a year, the hire overtakes the contractor and you should hire. At 60 or 90 days, the hire is paying for more than 100 empty days.

The number to go and find is not my rate. It is your dd, the honest count of days of senior work your plan actually contains. Most businesses of Calder Street's size, in my experience, are nearer 60 than 160.

What it costs to end it

Flexibility has a price in both directions. Ending an employment contract in the UK is governed by law, and the rules are reasonable, but they are rules, and they cost money and time at the exact moment you are trying to save both.

Notice. An employer must give at least one week's notice to someone employed between one month and two years, one week per year of service between two and 12 years, and 12 weeks after 12 years.8 Many contracts give more.

Redundancy pay. An employee with two or more years of service who is made redundant is entitled to statutory redundancy pay: half a week's pay for each full year under the age of 22, one week's pay for each year between 22 and 40, and one and a half weeks' pay for each year from 41. Service is capped at 20 years, weekly pay is capped at £751 for redundancies on or after 6 April 2026, and the maximum payment is £22,530.9

Unfair dismissal. Employees have protection against unfair dismissal, alongside the other rights that come with employee status,10 which means letting someone go for a reason other than redundancy needs a fair reason and a fair process. The exact law is a solicitor's job, not mine. The point for this article is only that ending an employment is a process, and processes take weeks of a managing director's attention.

Ending a contract with me is the notice period in the contract, and the handover I describe further down. I usually agree two to four weeks, or the end of the current milestone, whichever is cleaner.

Worked example: parting ways after three years

Suppose Calder Street hires the developer, and after three full years the big projects are done and the shop no longer needs a senior developer on the payroll. The developer is 35 and earns £65,000, which is £1,250 a week.

Statutory notice after three years is three weeks. Redundancy pay is one week per year, and since £1,250 is above the cap, each week counts as £751:

redundancy=3×751=2,253notice=3×1,250=3,750\text{redundancy} = 3 \times 751 = 2{,}253 \qquad \text{notice} = 3 \times 1{,}250 = 3{,}750

The redundancy is 3×7513 \times 751 because each of the three years counts as one week capped at £751. The notice is 3×1,2503 \times 1{,}250 because notice is paid at the actual weekly pay.

That is £6,003 before any enhanced terms in the contract, plus the consultation, the paperwork and the weeks of Rachel's time. The same ending with a contractor is a conversation, a notice period, a handover document and a last invoice.

IR35, in plain English, and why it matters to you

Any article about contractors in the UK has to deal with IR35, because it is the thing that makes finance directors nervous, and because a contractor who waves it away is a risk you are taking on.

The off payroll working rules, known as IR35, exist so that someone who works through their own company but would be an employee if the company were not in the way pays broadly the same tax and National Insurance as an employee.11 If an engagement is caught by the rules, the organisation that pays the fee has to deduct income tax and employee National Insurance from it and pay employer National Insurance on top, and the cost advantage you read about above shrinks a long way.

Who decides whether an engagement is caught depends on the size of the client. Since 6 April 2021, medium and large clients outside the public sector decide, and they must give the contractor a written status determination.1112 A client is medium or large if it meets two or more of three conditions: turnover above £10.2 million, a balance sheet total above £5.1 million, more than 50 employees. If it does not, it is small, and the responsibility for deciding stays with the contractor's own company.12

Two of those thresholds are moving. The Companies Act limits rose to £15 million of turnover and £7.5 million of balance sheet total for financial years beginning on or after 6 April 2025, with the 50 employee limit unchanged. HMRC's own manual says that, because a company is sized on an earlier financial year, the earliest tax year in which the change moves a client with a normal 12 month financial year out of the rules is 2027 to 2028.13 If you are near the line, ask your accountant which side of it you are on this year, not last.

Whoever decides, the test is the same: is this a genuine business to business engagement, or employment with a company wrapped round it? The signs that matter are familiar from any honest contract. Defined deliverables rather than a job description. The contractor's own equipment, own methods, own hours. A right to send a suitably skilled substitute. No obligation on either side to offer or accept work beyond the contract. Payment for outcomes and milestones rather than attendance. HMRC provides a Check Employment Status for Tax tool, and says it will stand by its result as long as the answers given were accurate.1214

I work through my own limited company, on scoped deliverables, with my own kit, and I run several clients at once. That is how I prefer to work anyway, and it happens to be what a genuine engagement looks like. I am not your accountant, and the determination is yours or mine depending on your size, so get it looked at. But do not let the acronym frighten you off the model. It is a test of whether the engagement is real, and a real one passes.

Worked example: is Calder Street small?

Calder Street Interiors has a turnover of £3 million, a balance sheet total well under £5.1 million and eight employees. It meets none of the three conditions, let alone two, so it is a small client. The decision on whether the rules apply sits with my company, not with Rachel. She asks me for it in writing before we start, and files it. If Calder Street grew to £11 million of turnover and 60 staff, two conditions would be met, the decision would move to Rachel, and she would issue the determination instead.

How an engagement with me runs

The model only works if the process behind it is clear, so here is how an engagement runs, from the first conversation to the last handover.

Tap or click to open full screen and move around

The diagram reads top to bottom. It starts with a free workshop, in which we map the problem, the outcome and what that outcome is worth to your business. Then I start the actual work, and the first two weeks are on me. Not a trial task, the real work, so that you judge me on how I handle your codebase and your people rather than on a slide. After two weeks you decide. If it is a no, we part well and you keep what I built. If it is a yes, the scope, the milestones, the day budget and the notice period go in writing, and we start properly.

Delivery is in the open. Everything lives in your repository, under your accounts, with tests on all of it, because I test everything I ship and because tests are the handover document that cannot go out of date. You see a working demo every week. Where the outcome is measurable in revenue, part of my fee can be tied to it, and I have written up how that works month by month.

Handover is not an event at the end. It is the state the work is in every Friday: documented, in your repository, under your credentials, with a short note on what comes next. When the engagement ends, planned or not, nothing is held hostage.

Worked example: Calder Street, month by month

January: the workshop. Rachel's list becomes four pieces of work with a value against each. The checkout alone is losing orders she can count. Late January: two weeks on me, in which the checkout's worst failure is fixed and shipped. February: Rachel says yes. We agree 90 days across the year, a milestone per piece of work, two weeks' notice either way. February to April: the new checkout, demoed weekly, live by Easter. May and June: the stock feed from the workshop. September and October: the B2B price list for trade customers, which is the piece she had not expected to afford this year. The small fixes fill the gaps. In December she has had 88 days, four finished pieces of work, and a repository her next developer, if she ever hires one, can read on their first morning.

Five questions to ask any contractor, including me

The honest risks of the model are the ones the old version of this article listed defensively. They are better as questions. Ask them of anyone you are about to engage, and ask them of me.

What happens if you are ill or unavailable? The answer you want is that nothing lives in their head only: documentation, tests, the repository under your accounts, and a note of where things stand, so another competent engineer could pick it up on Monday. If the answer is "I am never ill", keep looking.

What happens if you disappear? Same answer, plus the contract: a notice period both ways, a handover clause, and your ownership of everything you have paid for, in writing. I would add that a contractor with a public reputation and a limited company registered in England has rather a lot to lose by vanishing.

How will I know you are delivering? Milestones with acceptance criteria, a weekly demo, and the invoice tied to days actually worked or outcomes actually reached. You should never need to ask for a status report, because the status is the demo.

Who else are you working for? A contractor with other clients is not a problem, it is a sign of a genuine business, and it is also one of the signs HMRC looks for. What you need is a committed day budget per month and a realistic one. Over committing is the real risk, and the only cure is a contractor who says no.

What if we grow and need someone full time? Then you hire, and the contractor helps you do it: writes the job description from the real codebase, sits in on the technical interview, and hands over to the person you choose. I have done exactly that, and it is a good ending, not a bad one. The maths above tells you when that day is coming: watch your count of days.

When you should hire instead

The arithmetic is not shy. If your business genuinely needs 150 or more days of the same senior skill every year, year after year, the hire costs less, and you get the quieter benefits of someone who is there every day: the institutional memory, the mentoring of juniors, the availability when something breaks at 4pm on a Friday. When a client of mine reaches that point I say so, because the alternative is an engagement that starts to look like employment, which is bad for them under IR35 and bad for me as a way to work.

The contractor model is right when the work is lumpy, when it needs a level of experience you cannot keep busy all year, when the thing you need is a result rather than a presence, and when your plan contains 60 or 90 days of that work rather than 200. For most businesses of Calder Street's size, that describes nearly all of their technical work nearly all of the time.

The agency route is the third option, and I have kept it out of the sums on purpose, because it is a different article. In short: an agency sells you a team and a day rate per head, and the work is done by whoever on that team is free, with the senior person who sold it to you rarely the one writing the code. I have written about what outsourcing business critical development really costs and about how to choose an agency if you do go that way.

What you are buying from me is the thing the sums cannot show and the thing the diagram tries to: one senior person who scopes the work, writes the code, tests it, ships it, documents it, and is the same person on the phone when you have a question. I have written elsewhere about why that one person often beats a team, and about why I work this way at all. The short version is that accountability does not survive being shared.

Count your days. Then let us talk about the free workshop.

Sources

Count the days of senior work in your plan, then bring the number to a free workshop. The first two weeks of the actual work are on me, so you judge the model on your own codebase rather than on this article.

Sources

  1. 1.

    HM Revenue and Customs, Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027, GOV.UK, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/guidance/rates-and-thresholds-for-employers-2026-to-2027

  2. 2.

    HM Revenue and Customs, Claim Employment Allowance, GOV.UK, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/claim-employment-allowance

  3. 3.

    GOV.UK, Workplace pensions: what you, your employer and the government pay, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/workplace-pensions/what-you-your-employer-and-the-government-pay

  4. 4.
  5. 5.

    GOV.UK, Holiday entitlement, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights

  6. 6.

    GOV.UK, Statutory Sick Pay (SSP), 2026, https://www.gov.uk/statutory-sick-pay

  7. 7.

    GOV.UK, Employers' liability insurance, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/employers-liability-insurance

  8. 8.

    GOV.UK, Redundancy: your rights, notice periods, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/redundancy-your-rights/notice-periods

  9. 9.

    GOV.UK, Redundancy: your rights, redundancy pay, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/redundancy-your-rights/redundancy-pay

  10. 10.

    GOV.UK, Employment status: employee, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/employment-status/employee

  11. 11.

    HM Revenue and Customs, Understanding off payroll working (IR35), GOV.UK, 2024, https://www.gov.uk/guidance/understanding-off-payroll-working-ir35

  12. 12.

    HM Revenue and Customs, Off payroll working for clients, GOV.UK, 2024, https://www.gov.uk/guidance/off-payroll-working-for-clients

  13. 13.

    HM Revenue and Customs, Employment Status Manual ESM10006A: the small companies' regime, changes to the thresholds, GOV.UK, 2025, https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/employment-status-manual/esm10006a

  14. 14.

    HM Revenue and Customs, Check employment status for tax, GOV.UK, 2025, https://www.gov.uk/guidance/check-employment-status-for-tax